Lacey Brown who could make it to the first 12 finalists on her second time trip to Hollywood could not carry with his luck further. The loved one was the first one to go from this list on this season of American Idol. This time she was lucky to move so much because during her first stint she just missed the cut for the top 36. This time not only did she get past Hollywood Week to the top 24, she even made it to the top 12 and the big stage. To take benefits of the probable redemption of what’s called Judges’ Save, she repeated “The Story,” her best show overall.

And as it was expected like the first time it was very sweet with a fanciful wilt. But one could guess from the expression of Simon that he was not amenable to keeping her around. She was doomed. This was no shock for many viewers because she no doubt had been very appealing throughout the season like an unexpected flower popping up in city sidewalk, but she was anecdotal as a lice singer. As Simon said that she tried to approach each song as if she is a Hollywood actress and she could do music comedy better.

On the other hand Paige Miles joined Lacey in the bottom two. Her voice had been little low due to laryngitis but she still remained a powerful singer and can be compared to Siobhan Magnus. The night’s only surprise was Tim Urban and his survival in the final three as he could escape the bottom two or worse. He probably deserved the booting most but the judges start shaking heads as soon as he shows up and his Tuesday’s performance was cheerfully awful! But cuteness in American Idol plays a great role and that is what could have been seen in all these days.

Here are some random comments on the contestants from the judges:
Ellen said Siobhan had the budding of an Adam Lambert.
Randy said Lacey and Paige probably ought to have to be in the bottom two.
Kara, who at one point previously in the contest had said Katie Stevens could win, wouldn’t repeat that judgment when Ryan asked her about it. She darted and said in its place that Katie should try R&B-pop; Simon said, no, she should do country; Randy said, no, she should do pop-rock; and Ellen said, no, she should do mariachi. Katie’s head probably started to spin like the girl in The Exorcist.

The show began with some tensed movements with Ryan challenging Simon for not giving constructive criticism. “Do you want to get the eyeballing out of the way?” asked Simon. He told Ryan to stop crossing the line, literally and otherwise. Oooh! It’s hard to believe any of its real, except in a pro-wrestling sort of way. But both men played their parts well.